Q: Are some colors of light impossible? Can any color of light be made?

Physicist: Just so we can talk about this using physics rather than poetry, for the sake of this article “color” really means “frequency”.  Light frequency is a bit more objective than color and includes things we can’t see (like ultraviolet).

When you put gas in a tube and pass electricity through it you get light.  Electro-dynamically speaking, this is basically just beating the hell out of the atoms and letting the atoms ring like bells (only emitting light instead of sound).  Individual atoms are like simply shaped bells; the “tones” they make (or absorb) are very specific.  The colors emitted by atoms, their “spectra”, are different for different elements.  This is tremendously useful because it allows us to look at the light coming from something and immediately know what that thing is made of.

When given the energy (like in a neon light) atoms will emit light with very specific frequencies.  These are the lines for mercury, lithium, cadmium, strontium, calcium, and sodium that happen to fall in the visual spectrum.  There are many more lines that we mere humans can’t see.

Some colors fall into the gaps between the spectral lines of all elements (technically, almost all of them do).  So you can be forgiven for thinking that there are some colors that just never show up in nature.  Fortunately, there are a lot of effects that shift all those lines, blur them, or even split them.

Top: When a light source moves toward or away from you its spectrum is shifted up or down. Middle: In a hot gas the atoms are moving randomly, so whether the lines are Doppler shifted up or down is also random. This broadens the spectral lines. Bottom: With a very strong magnet you can change some of the electron’s energy levels and as a result transitions that would normally create the same color become separated.

So you can create any color by starting with a few distinct colors and then moving your light source either toward or away from an observer to Doppler shift one of your colors to the target color.  That’s a little like using a piano to get some notes, and then driving it around to get all the notes in-between.

An efficient means to play C above high C.

You can also just use a non-atomic source of light, like something that’s glowing hot, and then select out the color you want with a monochromator (the rest is chucked out).  But, as with any process that involves throwing out almost everything, this is remarkably inefficient.

Monocromators generate light with a single color (one might say “mono-chromatic” light) by just throwing away all the light that isn’t the right color.

So, say you want to create a very specific color of light with as little “waste light” as possible.  Well, a good place to start is lasers.  For some slick quantum reasons, the photons in laser beams are all kinda “clones” of each other; inside of any kind of laser device, the presence of the right kind of photon encourages the creation of other identical photons.  Pretty soon your laser is bubbling over with coherent, identical photons and not a lot else.  These share, among other things, a common color.

Laser beams: not a lot of colors.

It turns out that only a very small fraction of atomic spectral lines are good candidates for lasers.  It is possible to create laser light at any frequency between microwaves and X-rays, but the technique is a long way from efficient.  You can use the Doppler effect to change the color of your laser, but in order to make any significant change you’ll need to get it going a significant fraction of the speed of light.

If you want to efficiently create any very specific color of light, you just need to strap a laser to a starship.  So… no need to be picky.

An efficient means to make green light.

This entry was posted in -- By the Physicist, Physics, Quantum Theory, Relativity. Bookmark the permalink.

11 Responses to Q: Are some colors of light impossible? Can any color of light be made?

1. Sean says:

Maybe edit question title with NSFW, this isn’t ok in most workplaces.

2. Richard E. Peters, Jr. says:

As we identify new elements and isotopes, we will also find new light spectra that will correlate with those newly identified elements !!!

3. marcela shu says:

some colors appear exist mot,due the speed of light be constant might some atoms emit not certain colors,because each element has a spectrum of vibrations be very different,but some colors also absorb wavelength smallest. Is a question very difficult and Avery smart

4. stanley wallen says:

means nothing to me as I am a dog. Learning to type was hell and I still cant speel well

5. Rick says:

So what is the wavelength of purple?

6. Wes says:

The hair that breaks the camel’s back comes to mind.

Suppose we want to modify a laser to reproduce a certain frequency by mounting it on a rocket and carefully phase shifting the beam. Since energy comes in quanta, it seems that controlling the rocket to achieve infinite in-between speeds between two very close colors might be impossible. In other words, as we approach a calculated ideal speed, the energy for the extra force to accelerate the rocket just a tish faster, by the addition of just one more quanta (the hair), might make it go too fast and go ever so slightly too blue-like.

Or, conversely, we simply find the selection of infinite distance-over-time (i.e. mph) is fouled by a law of inviolate quanta time increments. Either way, the dilemma then becomes how could we insist that we can achieve infinite color selection with a rocket/laser combo? Granted there must be a heck of a lot of colors. But unless the size of quanta come in analog graduations (don’t think so), I think this may imply we must live in a jerky, notchy universe and our color selection might be permanently separated and rendered non-infinite by quantum effects. If so, how disappointing this must be to budding artists.
Wes

7. Jeff Pruett says:

There are colors we can perceive but that do not exist in nature. Red combined with Green for example…you’ve never heard of it’s name because it doesn’t exist in nature. But you CAN see it if you want to.

http://www.livescience.com/17948-red-green-blue-yellow-stunning-colors.html

There’s a trick you can use to see them, and I have done it. It is bizarre, because I don’t know how to describe what I saw. There is no common frame of reference in the real world. But I was able to see a color that was a blend of green and red. You can trick your eye into being able to see them briefly.

8. Sean says:

I think I will just need to unsubscribe as it doesn’t look like it’s going to change. It’s a shame I really enjoyed the discussions on my post about physicists and true randomness. I also loved talking about this sort of stuff with my niece as she is a very smart little 10 year old and we talked for hours on physics and ways for her to expand her thinking. I can’t have emails with pictures like this showing up in my emails as I open them at work and need a NSFW warning as I work in a child-safe workplace. Thanks for the good times. I will really miss this site, so long friends.

9. Ry says: