Category Archives: Skepticism

Q: Do you need faith to believe in science?

Mathematician: Well, what is faith? Let’s consult a dictionary. 1. Strong belief in God or in the doctrines of a religion, based on spiritual apprehension rather than proof This has nothing to do with science. 2. Complete trust or confidence in someone or … Continue reading

Posted in -- By the Mathematician, -- By the Physicist, Philosophical, Skepticism | 13 Comments

Q: Will the world end in 2012?

Physicist: Firstly, happy new year! So, there’s been a lot of hoopla around 2012 doomsday stuff for a while.  Maybe not as much fuss as there was over the techno-apocalypse of Y2K, but still.  Although there are a variety of … Continue reading

Posted in -- By the Physicist, Paranoia, Probability, Skepticism | 5 Comments

Q: CERN’s faster than light neutrino thing: WTF?

Physicist: The story here is that CERN has been generating neutrinos, firing them 730km, to a detector in Gran Sasso, Italy, and those neutrinos have been consistently (so far as their instruments say) arriving 60 ns (0.00000006 seconds) earlier than … Continue reading

Posted in -- By the Physicist, Experiments, Paranoia, Relativity, Skepticism | 20 Comments

Q: What’s the point of purely theoretical research?

Physicist: The classic answer to this question, due (possibly) to Franklin, is “what use is a new-born baby?”. The problem is that the best research/exploration is about looking for stuff, while not quite knowing what to expect or what to … Continue reading

Posted in -- By the Mathematician, -- By the Physicist, Experiments, Philosophical, Skepticism | Leave a comment

Q: How do I estimate the probability that God exists?

Mathematician: Before jumping into this question, it is important to realize that probabilities are not objective, observer independent quantities. We can think of the claim that a particular outcome will happen with a probability of 0.30 as meaning (loosely speaking) … Continue reading

Posted in -- By the Mathematician, Philosophical, Probability, Skepticism | 14 Comments

Q: Which is a better approach to quantum mechanics: Copenhagen or Many Worlds?

Physicist: The Copenhagen interpretation requires that new laws be created that, in addition to being impossible, are completely unnecessary, physically unfeasible, and utterly unjustifiable.  The basic laws of quantum mechanics, when applied at all scales, give you the Many Worlds … Continue reading

Posted in -- By the Physicist, Paranoia, Philosophical, Physics, Quantum Theory, Skepticism | 18 Comments