Q: How many mathematicians/physicists does it take to screw in a light bulb?

Mathematician:

Theorem (Bulb Screwing)

It only takes one mathematician to screw in a light bulb.

Proof:
Let the “bulb screwing number” N_{p} of a profession p, be the minimum number of people of profession p that must be assembled to screw in a light bulb. For any pair of professions p_{a} and p_{b} with p_{a} \ne p_{b} and N_{p_{b}} finite, there exists a “hiring” operation such that any one person of profession p_{a} can hire a collection of size N_{p_{b}} of appropriate people of profession p_{b} such that the collection of such people can screw in a light bulb. By the transitive property of light bulb screwing with respect to hiring, a single member of profession p_{a} can screw in a light bulb by hiring N_{p_{b}} people of profession p_{b} and therefore, so long as there exists a profession p_{b} \ne p_{a} with finite bulb screwing number, the existence of this hiring operation implies that the bulb screwing number N_{p_{a}} of p_{a} is at most 1. But, since we know there exists at least one light bulb that has been screwed in by at least one person of some non-mathematician profession, and there has only ever been a finite number of people, there must exist some other profession with finite bulb screwing number, so the bulb screwing number for mathematicians is 1. QED


Physicist: The computers capable of accurately doing this simulation haven’t been invented (yet).  So we’ve fallen back on some reasonable approximations, like massless light bulbs and spherical physicists.

So far, it looks like physicists can’t pick up light bulbs, but two physicists can break a bulb between them.

This is probably an NP problem or something, which means that the only remaining option is empirical research.  So, once the NSF frees up the funding for us to hire a team of experimental physicists (to experiment on), build a lab, and buy a light bulb, we’ll have something to publish in a year or two.

This entry was posted in -- By the Mathematician, -- By the Physicist, Brain Teaser, Philosophical. Bookmark the permalink.

23 Responses to Q: How many mathematicians/physicists does it take to screw in a light bulb?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *