Category Archives: — By the Mathematician

Q: Is π the same in every universe?

Mathematician: That depends on what you mean by “universe.”  Here’s a framing: A circle of radius R centered at a point P is the set of all points in the plane with distance R from P.  The diameter D of … Continue reading

Posted in -- By the Mathematician, -- By the Physicist, Geometry, Math, Philosophical | 27 Comments

Q: How do you answer a question scientifically?

Mathematician: Suppose you’re interested in answering a simple question: how effective is aspirin at relieving headaches? If you want to have conviction in the answer, you’ll need to think surprisingly carefully about how you approach this question. A first idea … Continue reading

Posted in -- By the Mathematician, Math, Philosophical, Probability | 4 Comments

Q: How would the universe be different if π = 3?

Physicist: We sometimes get questions about physical constants changing, and those questions make sense because there’s no real reason for the constants to be what they are.  But π is mathematically derivable; it kinda needs to be what it is.  You … Continue reading

Posted in -- By the Mathematician, -- By the Physicist, Geometry, Math, Philosophical, Physics | 45 Comments

Q: Are beautiful, elegant or simple equations more likely to be true?

Mathematician: It is not uncommon to hear physicists or mathematicians talk about the beauty, simplicity or elegance of equations or theorems, and even claim that they are sometimes led to a correct formula (or away from an incorrect one) by … Continue reading

Posted in -- By the Mathematician, Equations, Math, Philosophical, Physics | 13 Comments

π day!

We suddenly got hit with a barrage of π questions today.  Turns out it’s not a coincidence. π is defined, very humbly, as the ratio of the circumference of any circle to its diameter.  From that definition alone it’s managed … Continue reading

Posted in -- By the Mathematician, -- By the Physicist, Math | 16 Comments

Q: Do you need faith to believe in science?

Mathematician: This question could mean a few different things, depending on what is meant by the word “faith.” Let’s start with the dictionary definitions. 1. Strong belief in God or in the doctrines of a religion, based on spiritual apprehension rather than … Continue reading

Posted in -- By the Mathematician, -- By the Physicist, Philosophical, Skepticism | 30 Comments