Q: If there are 10 dimensions, then why don’t we notice them?

Physicist: A “dimension” is a direction.  So, we’re in “3 dimensions” because there are only 3 directions, and every other direction is just a combination of those 3 (and their negatives).  For example, by telling someone how far north, east, and up to go you can direct them anywhere on Earth.  Time is also considered to be a dimension, but there are some subtleties involved with that.

When string theorists talk about space having 10 dimensions they’re talking about all but four of those being “tiny loop dimensions”.  We’re used to thinking of a direction/dimension as extending outward forever, but these tiny directions just make a short loop and bring you back to where you started.

A loop dimension is a direction that repeats.  Sorta like this.

For example, if the universe had two normal dimensions, and the third dimension was a “1-meter loop dimension” then you could move, say, north/south and up/down no problem, but if you looked east or west you’d see the back of your head a meter away.  But unlike a mirror, you could physically poke the back of your head.  Or give yourself a haircut, because why not.

The smaller dimensions are like that, but loop on a distance that is much, much smaller than the smallest particle.  As a result, it doesn’t really make sense to talk about movement in these tiny dimensions, basically because there’s no place to go.

If you restrict one dimension enough, then it can be effectively ignored.  If you’re as big as the alley then you can’t move left-right, but you can still move forward-backward and up-down.

So, if you want to avoid being hit by something, you just step to the side (in any of our 3 dimensions).  You have the option because you have the room.  In the loop dimensions there isn’t enough room, so as far as we (and even particles) are concerned, they may as well not be there.

String theory (which is where all this “10 dimension” talk is coming from) is the only theory of everything on the table today, but unfortunately it hasn’t made any verifiable predictions (yet).  The extra, but undetectable, dimensions are just one example of that.

The portal picture is from here, and the alleyway photo is from here.

This entry was posted in -- By the Physicist, Physics. Bookmark the permalink.

14 Responses to Q: If there are 10 dimensions, then why don’t we notice them?

  1. Chaoky says:

    Short Answer: For the same reason flatlanders on a piece of paper don’t notice that the piece of paper thy live on exists in 3 dimensions (or 10).

  2. vertical says:

    next question: if these extra dimensions have no room for anything, why does string theory have them?

  3. waseem says:

    good question but the fourth dimension is not understood yet so we cannot get to fifth unless we understand time or what ever it is

  4. The Physicist The Physicist says:

    When quantum physicists see quantized values, they immediately begin to suspect that there are some hidden restrictions somewhere in the system. For example, sound waves in air can have (practically) any wavelength, but sound waves on a guitar string can only show up in a tiny, discrete, set of wavelengths that divide the length of the string (these are called the harmonics).
    Particles themselves are discrete, and have properties like charge, lepton flavor, baryon number, etc. that are all discrete integer numbers. One of the reasons behind coming up with these extra tiny dimensions is that they introduce a restriction (the size of the dimension) which makes standing waves show up in integer multiples of some set frequency, similar to the way the fixed length of a guitar string forces a particular set.

  5. larry walden says:

    So…if there are 10 dimensions, can there existence be proved by experiment? And would one be able observe them in some way.

  6. The Physicist The Physicist says:

    They probably can’t be observed directly, but there may be some very slick way to detect them through some secondary effects and clever math.

  7. vishal nair says:

    so if. then if i travel at the speed of light and if could see mirror behind while travelling at the speed of light what kind of dimension would i see at mirror.

  8. The Wonderer says:

    How bout the ‘brane theory’ saying we live in a 3 dimensional ‘brane’ but our ‘brane’ is right up against other ‘branes’ that can be 4, 5, 10 or any number of dimensions there are.

  9. larry walden says:

    I could not resist commenting on this one: Those who espouse the the Brane Theory have little or no “brains” (please smile)

  10. larry walden says:

    Yes my moderation is: it was just a pun..a joke not meant to do any harm. Come on fellow scientists lighten up. The second law of thermodynamics says we are not going to live forever (at least on this planet) so enjoy your work. I promise to be a better fellow human being and not be such a wise guy. amen

  11. Quantum says:

    Can’t waves of small amplitutes nd longer wave lengths move through this dimensions?

  12. munna says:

    There is one clue which helps to understand dimensions. For example to explain time as a dimension in 4D- 3-space and one time dimension, we can assume the body at rest and think of time passing. i.e a body at rest will have (0,0,0) space dimension and time dimension as “T”. So the time passed between two events for a body at rest is t2-t1 and the initial and final coordinates are given as (ct,,0,0,0) and final coordinates are (ct2,0,0,o). Similarly to understand 5th dimension we must assume body at rest in time dimension too and think of dimension that is moving.

  13. Observer says:

    I read another article about 10 dimensions where dimensions 5 through 10 were described as “possibilities”. The following video also describes this concept (http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=p4Gotl9vRGs)

    I just wanted to ask whether this concept has scientific merit and is this in any way related to the way 10 dimensions are described in your article.

  14. Flaming Svin says:

    The reason for why we can’t see the fourth dimensions is the reason for why flat landers can’t percieve the depth .

    Some phycisist say that the 5th dimension could be the orthogonal of that of the fourth.Time moves in one direction further more it is a line in a representation of the 4d.The 5thcould be the possibility of every casualty or the parallel worlds to be simplified.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>