Q: What is the state of matter in deep space?

The original question was: What might be the state of matter in [interstellar space]. Average temperature is 2.7K , so all the gases like hydrogen, helium should be in liquid or solid state?

Physicist: Matter in deep space tends to take the form of gas.  Liquids basically don’t happen, and solids are pretty rare.  The cosmic microwave background ensures that everything is at least as hot as about 2.7K, but in general the gases we see out there are quite a bit hotter.  Fortunately, there’s so little of it that you’d barely notice.

Sure it's hot, but there isn't much of it so there isn't enough heat to light things on fire.

Sure it’s hot, but there’s so little of it that there isn’t enough heat to light things on fire.  The same thing is true for gases in space: it’s hot, but there’s so little of it you’d never notice.

For example, in the core of the Orion Nebula the temperature of the gas is around 10,000K, but even if you were there your biggest problem wouldn’t be getting burned, it would be freezing to death.  Also suffocation.  Really, if you’re going to travel in space at all, bring a spacesuit.

Temperature is a measure of the average random speed of a material (technically, it’s the “variance” of the velocities).  That “random” bit is important.  For example, the air you’re (hopefully) breathing isn’t sitting still, it’s moving every-which-way at around half a km per second.  Air bounces around so much that it doesn’t get very far (about 1 ten millionth of a meter before it gets bounced), but it’s all still moving pretty fast.

By comparison, Halley’s comet is moving at a few dozen km/s (it varies between about 1 km/s and 50 km/s).  However, it’s frozen because that movement isn’t random.  Its atoms are all moving really fast, but they’re all moving together.

A comet moves faster than air molecules (on average), but it's still frozen solid.

(left) a hot air balloon and (right) an artist’s interpretation of a comet.  Temperature is the random movement of molecules.  A comet moves faster than air molecules (on average), but it’s still frozen solid because all of its molecules are moving in more-or-less the same direction.  The air molecules  in a hot air balloon move fast (relative to each other) and the bits of ice in the comet moves slowly (relative to each other).

Here comes the point.  In deep space you mostly find individual atoms cruising along at high speeds.  In order to define a temperature you look at lots of atoms passing through a region and see how random those trajectories are.  Typically: they’re very random and very fast, so the temperature of those gases is thousands of degrees Celsius (or Kelvin or Fahrenheit for that matter).

It’s not unusual for things to be randomly traveling through space really fast: space is full of stuff taking forever to go from nowhere to nowhere through nothing at break-neck speeds.  Generally, unless there’s a good reason to do otherwise, the individual atoms in space are traveling in every-which-way.  A “good reason” is often running into something, or being caught up in an accretion disk.  The majority of molecules in deep space are traveling in a straight line, very fast, without (strongly) interacting with anything else for years at a time.

A natural question to ask is: Isn’t space cold?  If this interstellar gas is so damnably hot, then why doesn’t it cool off?  The answers are: “yes it is” and “you have to think about why things cool off”.  Light is created by accelerating charges.  Traveling in a straight line involves no acceleration.  If things bounce off of each other a lot, then they change direction a lot and that involves (for lack of a better word) a lot of accelerating.

This has nothing to do with either the spirit or letter of the question, but one of the most terribly cool things ever is that entire stars obey the same rules; they travel along at high speeds without interacting with anything else for huge periods of time.  While atoms scatter by bouncing off of each other, stars interact with each other through their gravity (it’s very, very rare for stars to actually run into each other).  If you stand back far enough, you find that the stars in a galaxy act a lot like a gas.  You can even describe the “temperature” of a galaxy and talk about the movement of its stars in terms of thermodynamics.  For example, “hot galaxies” are those with lots of randomly moving stars, and these galaxies literally evaporate (eject stars into inter-galactic space) and “cool” as a result.  As they “cool” the randomness of their remaining stars’ movements decrease and the galaxy itself tends to contract.

This entry was posted in -- By the Physicist, Astronomy, Physics. Bookmark the permalink.

11 Responses to Q: What is the state of matter in deep space?

  1. MadhuS says:

    My question may be stupid, please excuse 🙂 How does the heat propagate? Say, from the Sun to the earth, in empty Space? There is nothing to carry the heat right? or do we feel the heat only after the rays (?) hit the atmosphere and the atoms of the atmosphere start moving randomly ?? Please explain. Thanks!

  2. The lay person says:

    Heat from the Sun is sent to us through photons. The photons come from the sun and hit our bodies and the ground, and they heat up. (I don’t know just how photons set the atoms jiggling.) The ground then warms the atmosphere by the atoms bumping into each other.

  3. Manuel Cheta says:

    @Lay person

    Photons are absorbed by the atoms and they start jiggling more and more.

    We also emit photons in the IR range 😀

  4. Avaratatat says:

    Hey, nice explanation, Mr/Ms. Physicist. I like the down to earth tone and the nice attempt at explaining difficult phenomena in everyday words.

    I’ll take a layperson shot at the comment section- photons come in packets and are absorbed in quanta (hence that thing called Quantum Mechanics), when they are absorbed they transfer energy which causes the recipient whatsoever to have more energy than it’s used to (compared to it’s usual condition), it (the recipient) then radiates the excess energy off as another type of photon, maybe in infrared range, but as some discrete value (why it’s called “Quanta”). We know this commonly as heat.

  5. Avaratatat says:

    The answer for MadhuS is that the energy comes as radiation, radiation doesn’t need a carrier, it just moves away from the source.

  6. MadhuS says:

    Radiation is nothing but photon?

  7. The Physicist The Physicist says:

    @MadhuS
    When you feel heat from a fire or the Sun what you’re feeling is light energy, which is sometimes called “radiation” or “radiant heat”. Radiation from a radioactive material is also called radiation, and it is also often light, but it’s pretty different stuff.

  8. Elvince Ager says:

    i read that the tae of matter in most of the cosmos is PLASMA. i ddint believe it can sam1 be of assistant.

  9. Ansh Sharma says:

    Radiation is nothing but photon?

  10. Douglas D. B. says:

    We shall never truly “see” a photon. But in space it oscillates as energy and point mass.

  11. Yme says:

    The space atoms move in, is that non-matter?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *